Readers' Letters: Pedestrianisation move would be cataclysmic for capital
Council’s move to ban traffic from Edinburgh’s George Street would be a disaster, says reader
The cataclysmic news that Edinburgh Council has approved the pedestrianisation of George Street was hidden away in the Around Scotland section of Saturday’s Scotsman.
This ridiculous decision is yet another blow to the citizens and retailers of Edinburgh, especially those of us for whom walking is difficult, cycling impossible and carrying bulky packages on buses similarly impossible. All this is in the name of creating a “boulevard society” of shops and cafes where happy visitors and locals can stroll along George Street, chatting jovially to young and old alike, ignoring the driving rain and freezing winds.
We must resist this nonsense if we want our city to remain somewhere everyone can enjoy. In addition, the knock-on effects of driving all the traffic into Queen Street will create gridlock and chaos. A public campaign against this decision is absolutely necessary.


Brian Bannatyne-Scott, Edinburgh
Strong reaction
In “Ministers have failed to explain the need for data centres, say campaigners” (14 November), a Scottish government spokesman tells us planning guidance will be forthcoming before the end of the year, along with a strategic approach to maximise public benefit.
Meanwhile, here in Dumfriesshire, it was suggested the proposed "biggest in the world" data centre at Chapelcross might be used as a way for Westminster to impose a “Small Modular (nuclear) Reactor” (SMR) at the site to meet the considerable energy demand. While ScotGov is reviewing their guidance, has the possibility of unwanted back-door nuclear gone under their radar?
Our local (Tory) MP, David Mundell, faced with the not inconsiderable opposition from folk in Dumfries & Galloway to this data centre, has now come out and said that – whether the data centre goes ahead or not – a SMR should be imposed at Chapelcross.
With the power needs any such data centre will require, I hope our Holyrood government isn't having the wool pulled over their eyes or, worse, is going along with data centres as a way of excusing a lifting of the moratorium against nuclear.
Ian Waugh, Dumfries
Nets needed
At last, good news on growth in the economy! Real growth in Quarter 3 of 2026 was 0.7 per cent according to figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS). With the exception of the US, this outstripped growth in the G7. This also breaks the seasonal pattern where economic momentum in the UK is frequently lost in the third quarter. If continued, this would represent an annualised growth rate of 2.4 per cent, unprecedented in recent times.
A long-awaited moment to savour? Not quite. Examination of the factors driving the change and the circumstances of the moment reveal a curious irony. According to the ONS, quarter-three growth was powered not by consumers, but by business-to-business spending, in the main on AI and cloud computing, investment roll-out of data centres, back-office and support services related to the adoption of digital and AI tools etc.
Meanwhile, the Microsoft outage, in combination with the antics of Jensen Huang, ex-CEO of Nvidia, are sending shock waves throughout the digital economy that are leaving a bad taste in the mouths of consumer, investors and governments alike.
Nvidia is the chip-lynchpin of the AI ecosystem and Microsoft is the world’s largest software company. They are digital leviathans – only Apple is bigger. As if it were needed, the two incidents have provided further hard evidence of the serious risks and dangers countries, organisations and individuals run due to their high and growing dependence on digital technology.
While we clearly need the growth and productivity benefits these technologies bring, it cannot be at all costs. Affirmative action is needed to mitigate these risks and dangers. We urgently need more effective “digital safety nets” .
Ewen Peters, Newton Mearns, East Renfrewshire
Patients first
Stan Grodynski complains of the apparent “creeping privatisation of the Health Service in England” as though this is a bad thing if it is true (Letters, 14 November). A Health Service exists to provide a fit for purpose service to the public. There are far too many examples in Scotland and in England where, despite the best efforts of staff and the enormous amounts of money thrown at it, the NHS is simply not delivering in many areas despite excelling in some. Long waits to see a GP, A&E backed up because ambulances cannot unload patients and move to the next emergency, even longer waits to see a consultant about a hip problem (73 weeks in my case with up to three years to have a replacement hip) are just some examples. If the NHS can use private services which can help the patient promptly and cost effectively, their use should be encouraged.
Examples already are cataracts where the use of private providers can provide prompt relief to sufferers who would otherwise have long waits in the NHS.
The debate should not be private or public, but co-operation. Where the private sector can deliver effective services to the patient, then the NHS should consider using it.
The private sector has its faults, as does the NHS, but the focus should be on the service to the patient, not on protecting the body that is the NHS. Precluding the use of the private sector because of some belief that only the NHS can treat us is simply wrong, and puts the most important person – the patient – behind an ideological belief only the NHS should deliver healthcare. If Healthcare remains free at the point of delivery, and the private sector can play a positive part alongside the NHS, then its use should be welcomed.
Brian Barbour, Haddington, East Lothian
Write to The Scotsman
We welcome your thoughts – NO letters submitted elsewhere, please. Write to [email protected] including name, address and phone number – we won't print full details. Keep letters under 300 words, and in the body of the email – no attachments – and avoid 'Letters to the Editor/Readers’ Letters' or similar in your subject line. If referring to an article, include date, page number and heading. No poems.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.